Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Different Takes: New Abortion Rule Is An Assault On Health Care Work Force; Finally, Planned Parenthood Is Exposed For What It Really Is
Trump鈥檚 rebranding of the Gag Rule marks a frontal assault on human rights 鈥 not just for the four million patients that Title X providers serve annually, but also the community-based health care providers that struggle to narrow abysmal gaps in healthcare services. (The new domestic gag rule is a reflection of a similar anti-abortion rule for international aid funding instituted by every Republican administration since Ronald Reagan.) By muddling medicine and religious orthodoxy, moreover, the Gag Rule also threaten to erode the ethical integrity of the health care workforce, imposing the impossible choice on clinicians to either obey the law that funds their programs, or to uphold ethical responsibilities to their patients. (Michelle Chen, 2/25)
Planned Parenthood wants to be considered a benevolent health-care provider rather than the nation鈥檚 largest abortion business, and it wants the cachet of the federal government鈥檚 treating it as a valued and non-controversial partner. Hence the frequent, though聽long-debunked, claim that abortion makes up a mere 3 percent of the organization鈥檚 activities. Planned Parenthood鈥檚 own annual report tells the real tale: Last fiscal year alone, its facilities performed upwards of 332,000 abortion procedures, well over one-third the estimated abortions in the entire country. Its new president, Leana Wen, was more candid last month when she said that 鈥減rotecting and expanding access to abortion鈥 is the group鈥檚 鈥渃ore mission.鈥 (2/26)
In its continuing assault on reproductive rights, the Trump administration has issued potentially devastating changes to the nation鈥檚 nearly 50-year-old family planning program, Title X, which allows millions of women each year to afford contraception, cancer screenings and other critical health services. Health clinics have long been barred from using Title X money, or any federal funds, to pay for abortions, but they have been able to provide abortions and other family planning services under one roof. (2/26)
Republicans have long used their party鈥檚 opposition to abortion as a rallying cry and a way to turn out voters. Now, they seem to be gearing up to make abortion a core issue in the 2020 race. A key component of that strategy: painting Democrats as radical baby-killers. This week, Senate Republicans advocated a bill that seemed designed to do just that. (Eugene Scott, 2/26)
Trump announced that his administration will bar organizations that provide abortion referrals from participating in the $286 million Title X federal family-planing program that serves more than 4 million patients, mostly low-income women. Congress can鈥檛 make it right. Not with Trump poised to veto corrective legislation. (2/26)
On Feb. 5, during the State of the Union address, President Trump implied that women like me executed our babies after birth. On Tuesday, he repeated that same lie on Twitter after the nonsensical Born-Alive Abortion Survivors Act failed to gain enough votes in the Senate to move forward. The bill would have put in place requirements for the care of infants born after failed abortions and might have locked up doctors who failed to comply. It is unclear how this bill might affect situations where parents decline, for medically appropriate reasons, to have their newborns resuscitated. The threat of criminal prosecution does not enhance anyone鈥檚 medical care. (Jen Gunter, 2/26)