Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Different Takes: Since Health Care Is No. 1 Issue, Expect All The Important Answers During The Debates; Where Was The Fight Among Progressives?
Health care is the number one issue on the minds of Democratic voters: Nearly 9 in 10 of them saying they want the topic discussed during the presidential candidate debates. Indeed, all candidates vying for the Democratic nomination seem to agree that everyone should have health care coverage, marking a huge step forward. After all, not long ago advocating for 鈥渦niversal鈥 coverage was highly sensitive political territory. But many candidates have been vague and noncommittal about how, exactly, they want to reform our health care system. Voters deserve the opportunity to understand the real, significant differences between each candidate鈥檚 approach to this critical issue. As voters watch the debates this week, they should pay close attention to the candidates鈥 answers (and non-answers) to these three key questions. (Arthur ''Tim'' Garson, Jr. and Ryan Holeywell, 7/30)
It was the Detroit Donnybrook. Tuesday鈥檚 Democratic debate was choppy but passionate, opening up wide philosophical divisions within the party鈥檚 presidential field and providing sound bites critical of progressive ideas and candidates that Republicans are certain to use in 2020. Moderate candidates trailing in the polls went in determined to upend Sens.聽Elizabeth Warren (Mass.) and Bernie Sanders (Vt.), the two strongest candidates on the stage and leaders of the party鈥檚 left. Warren and Sanders were still standing at the end. Warren was consistently crisp, displaying the mastery-on-the-run that has lifted her in the polls. (E.J. Dionne Jr. 7/31)
It wasn鈥檛 the debate result many in the media wanted. Author Marianne Williamson was the surprise star of a debate where she had very little time compared to her opponents 鈥 less than half that of the big-name candidates. Williamson鈥檚 debate strategy was to push for 鈥渞adical truth-telling.鈥 This included a call for up to $500 billion in reparations for African-Americans and some tough talk about the Flint, Michigan, water crisis that won her loud support in the Detroit audience. New York Times reporter Katie Benner pointed out how Williamson used Flint 鈥渢o tackle the issue of racism head on.鈥 (Dan Gainor, 7/30)
I鈥檓 no good at sartorial stuff, so I can鈥檛 describe how Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren were actually dressed. But I can tell you what they were effectively wearing: targets. They came into the debate in Detroit on Tuesday night not just as the highest-polling candidates among the 10 on the stage, but also as the most ardent progressives, with plans more expansive and expensive than their rivals鈥. That gave those rivals both the motivation and the means to attack. (Frank Bruni, 7/31)
Just in time for her second Democratic presidential debate appearance, on Wednesday night, Sen. Kamala D.聽Harris (Calif.) has unveiled a Medicare-for-all plan.聽The timing of Harris鈥檚 release is excellent news for health-care wonks; now CNN鈥檚 Dana Bash, Don Lemon and Jake Tapper will have an opportunity to ask her to fill in the plan鈥檚 somewhat scanty details. Here are some questions about Harris鈥檚 Medicare-for-all plan the debate moderators might want to consider. (Megan McArdle, 7/30)
When did so many of our elected leaders become so uncompromising on health care? Was it the moment when many in the Democratic field raised their hands in support of providing subsidized health insurance to all undocumented immigrants? That鈥檚 a position that even our peer countries with better coverage rates have yet to embrace. (Vin Gupta, 7/30)
After months of confusing statements on the campaign trail, Sen. Kamala D. Harris (D-Calif.) has finally released her proposal to offer comprehensive, universal health-care coverage under the Medicare-for-all brand. Harris鈥檚 rollout Monday was met with swift criticism from both the Biden camp, which called it 鈥淎 Bernie Sanders-lite Medicare for All,鈥 and the Sanders camp, which insists Harris 鈥渃an鈥檛 call [her] plan Medicare for All.鈥 (Charles Gaba, 7/30)
Opponents have accused the Trump administration of taking a fragmented, inconsistent approach toward the health-care system. They are wrong. There is a definite overriding strategy which favors deregulation and the re-introduction of market forces to provide more choices for patients, while at the same time protecting the essential pieces of the existing system 鈥 namely, employer-based insurance, Medicare and Medicaid. (Marc Siegel, 7/30)
There may come a day when we here in America have settled our major arguments about what sort of health-care system we should have and all that remains is making minor adjustments to something whose basic structure is no longer a point of contention. This is not that day. But this day is the anniversary of the day 54 years ago when President Lyndon B. Johnson signed the bill that created Medicare and Medicaid. (Paul Waldman, 7/30)
鈥業f I鈥檓 elected president,鈥 Joe Biden says, 鈥渨e鈥檙e going to cure cancer.鈥 Mr. Biden has a personal interest in the disease, which killed his son Beau in 2015. But the Obama-Biden administration had a bad record on screening, the best way to save patients from cancer. When Barack Obama was president, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force鈥攁 panel of experts in the Health and Human Services Department, whose advice guides coverage decisions for both private and government insurance鈥攁rgued that screening should be limited to prevent false positives, which the panel claimed cause distress and unnecessary further testing. (Betsy McCaughey, 7/30)