Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Gruber, In Hill Testimony, Apologizes And Plays Down His Role In Crafting Health Law
鈥淚'm a professor of economics at MIT. I'm not a politician nor a political advisor," Gruber said, stressing that his role with the administration was purely technical. "I did not draft Governor Romney鈥檚 health care plan, and I was not the 鈥榓rchitect鈥 of President Obama鈥檚 health care plan.鈥 The hearing featured several terse exchanges, which highlighted the lighting rod Gruber has become and the sharp partisan divisions surrounding the ACA. (DelReal, 12/9)
Mr. Gruber testified with Marilyn Tavenner, administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, to the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. Republicans had criticized both for statements they say show a pattern of deception by the Obama administration in passing and implementing the 2010 law. Both Republicans and Democrats sharply criticized Mr. Gruber for his comments. The remarks reveal 鈥渁 pattern of intentional misleading鈥 of the public about the Affordable Care Act, said Rep. Darrel Issa (R., Calif.), chairman of the committee. Rep. Elijah Cummings of Maryland, the top Democrat on the panel, said Mr. Gruber鈥檚 statements 鈥済ave Republicans a public-relations gift in their relentless political campaign to tear down the ACA and eliminate health care for millions of Americans.鈥 (Armour, 12/9)
Jonathan Gruber, the health economist whose incendiary comments about 鈥渢he stupidity of the American voter鈥 have embarrassed the Obama administration, apologized on Tuesday for what he described as his 鈥済lib, thoughtless and sometimes downright insulting comments.鈥 鈥淚 am not a political adviser nor a politician,鈥 said Dr. Gruber, a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who was a paid consultant to the Obama administration in 2009 to 2010. (Pear, 12/9)
Jonathan Gruber, an MIT professor who worked on the Affordable Care Act, apologized to members of Congress on Tuesday for a series of controversial comments he made about the law, which Republicans have seized on to attack the healthcare legislation. 鈥淚 behaved badly, and I will have to live with that,鈥 Gruber told the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform. 鈥淏ut my own inexcusable arrogance is not a flaw in the Affordable Care Act. The ACA is a milestone accomplishment for our nation that already has provided millions of Americans with health insurance.鈥 (Levey, 12/9)
Gruber told groups in 2012 and 2013 that voter stupidity and a 鈥渓ack of transparency鈥 were important to passing the hard-fought legislation. Appearing before the House Oversight committee Tuesday, Gruber expanded on earlier apologies, repeatedly saying 鈥淚 was conjecturing in areas beyond my expertise.鈥 Enduring one fierce lecture after another, Gruber said his earlier comments were uninformed, 鈥済lib, thoughtless and sometimes downright insulting.鈥 He said he was showing off before various groups, and 鈥渢rying to be something, I鈥檓 not, which was a political expert.鈥 (Babington, 12/9)
Still, Tuesday鈥檚 House hearing never forced Gruber to admit what Republicans wanted to prove: that he was speaking from inside knowledge of the writing of the Affordable Care Act, and therefore had confirmed that Obamacare was a fraud all along. And as much as the Republicans grilled him, Gruber never budged from his story, whether they wanted to believe it or not: He ran numbers for Obamacare, didn鈥檛 really know the political strategies he talked about so freely, and did not, in fact, confirm the premise of a lawsuit over subsidies that could give the Supreme Court a new opportunity to unravel the health care law next year. (Nather, 12/9)
MIT economist Jonathan Gruber apologized before a congressional committee Tuesday for calling American voters stupid and a number of comments saying that the administration deceived the American public to pass Obamacare almost five years ago. Gruber's much-anticipated testimony tried to serve two main goals 鈥 apologize for the comments that opened up Obamacare to new scrutiny and do his best to distance himself from the drafting of the health-care law. (MIllman, 12/9)
Gruber also drew the ire of committee Republicans for not disclosing all his income from state and federal consulting contracts, and Oversight Committee Chairman Darrell Issa threatened to subpoena information on how much Gruber was paid for all of his Affordable Care Act work. Gruber, who has been a sought-after speaker in recent years, advised Washington and a number of states. Gruber would only confirm he received close to $400,000 under a contract with HHS and referred the committee to his attorney to determine what other payments may be released. (Norman, 12/9)
Jonathan Gruber, the embattled former White House consultant and key architect of Obamacare, spent the morning engaged in an awkward battle with lawmakers during a House Oversight Committee hearing about his role in the president鈥檚 health care law. (Ehley, 12/9)
The committee also questioned an administration official about a misstep in calculating enrollment numbers -
The committee also questioned Marilyn Tavenner, the administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, for giving misleading enrollment numbers in previous testimony in September. Tavenner testified that 7.3 million people had signed up for health insurance on state and federal exchanges, but she acknowledged that the number included dental plans 鈥 therefore double-counting almost 400,000 subscribers. (Korte, 12/9)
The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has turned over 19,000 pages of ObamaCare enrollment data to a House committee controlled by Republicans. The administration provided the papers just before a high-profile hearing on the healthcare law. An agency official confirmed the documents have been given to the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee. The panel had requested more details about how HHS has counted its healthcare sign-ups after a GOP-led investigation found that the agency had been misreporting its enrollment total. (Ferris, 12/9)