Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
House GOP Sues Obama On Health Law
After searching for months to find an attorney who would take their case, House Republicans made good on their threat to sue the Obama administration Friday, filing a lawsuit challenging the president's authority to enact key parts of the Affordable Care Act. The case has been considered a long shot by legal scholars, as the Supreme Court has repeatedly rebuffed members of Congress suing on constitutional grounds. (Levey, 11/21)
The suit accuses the Obama administration of unlawfully postponing a requirement that larger employers offer health coverage to their full-time employees or pay penalties. (Larger companies are defined as those with 50 or more employees.) ... The suit also challenges what it says is President Obama鈥檚 unlawful giveaway of roughly $175 billion to insurance companies under the law. According to the Congressional Budget Office, the administration will pay that amount to the companies over the next 10 years, though the funds have not been appropriated by Congress. (Parker, 11/21)
The House鈥檚 lawsuit against the Obama administration鈥檚 implementation of Obamacare includes a new charge against the law鈥檚 cost-sharing provisions. The suit says the administration has no authority to make payments to insurers to fund the cost-sharing program, as it began doing in January. The complaint contends the health care law requires cost-sharing payments from the insurers 鈥 presumably with the understanding that the government would repay them 鈥 but doesn鈥檛 make those payments contingent on the government and Congress appropriating the funding. (Haberkorn, 11/21)
House Speaker John Boehner (R., Ohio) said in a statement that lawmakers had an obligation to act to protect the Constitution. 鈥淭ime after time, the president has chosen to ignore the will of the American people and rewrite federal law on his own without a vote of Congress. That鈥檚 not the way our system of government was designed to work,鈥 he said. (Crittenden and Kendall, 11/21)
The move was expected for months -- the GOP-controlled House of Representatives voted to approve the lawsuit in July. But Boehner had trouble retaining a law firm that would take the case because of the political furor over the controversial health care law. (Walsh and Bash, 11/21)
The White House dismissed the lawsuit Friday as meritless and as a waste of money. 鈥淚nstead of passing legislation to help expand the middle class and grow the economy, Speaker Boehner and House Republicans are spending hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars pursuing a lawsuit that is without any sound legal basis,鈥 White House spokeswoman Brandi Hoffine said. (Gerstein and French, 11/21)
[The suit] appeared to be choreographed to burnish the GOP鈥檚 narrative of President Barack Obama as a ruler who thinks he鈥檚 above the law. (Douglas, Doyle and Pugh, 11/21)
The lawsuit, filed in federal court in Washington, D.C. and drafted by George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley, escalates a brewing battle between GOP lawmakers and the Obama administration over separation of powers. Here鈥檚 a quick overview of its legal arguments. (Gershman, 11/21)