Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Senate Rolls Back Obama-Era Ban On States Blocking Funding For Clinics That Provide Abortions
Senate Republicans, aided by Vice President Mike Pence and an ailing Georgia colleague who gingerly made his way to the Capitol with the aid of a wheelchair and a walker, voted Thursday to undo an Obama administration rule preventing states from blocking funding for family planning clinics that also provide abortions. (Steinhauer, 3/30)
The bill erases a regulation imposed by former President Barack Obama shortly before he left office that lets states deny family planning funds to organizations only if they are incapable of providing those services. Some states have passed laws in recent years denying the money to groups that provide abortions. (Jalonick and Fram, 3/30)
The measure, a priority for groups that oppose abortion, would give a thumbs-up to Tennessee and other conservative states to resume policies blocking Planned Parenthood clinics from getting federal funding through the Title X family-planning program. Those dollars can鈥檛 be used for abortions, but conservatives feel abortion providers shouldn鈥檛 receive any taxpayer funds. While courts have not allowed states to withhold Medicaid money from Planned Parenthood, they鈥檝e generally allowed states to redirect family-planning dollars to other health providers. (Cunningham, 3/30)
Pence cast the deciding 51st vote in favor of nixing the rule, after the legislation stalled in a 50-50 tie.聽Republican Sens. Lisa Murkowski (Alaska) and Susan Collins (Maine) sided with Democrats to vote against repealing the Obama-era rule, prompting the need for the vice president to break the tie. (Carney, 3/30)
鈥淲e鈥檙e talking about federal family planning funds and I don鈥檛 think that those funds should be subjected to state restrictions,鈥 Collins told POLITICO. 鈥淚t鈥檚 important to recognize that there is already a bar against using federal funds for abortion and that bar stays in effect. That鈥檚 a prohibition that I personally support, but I鈥檓 a strong supporter of family planning funds.鈥 A spokesperson for Murkowski said the vote is "consistent with the senator's long-held belief that men and women should have access to the family planning and reproductive health services they need, including cancer tests and health screenings." (Kim and Ehley, 3/30)
The Republicans needed 51 votes to clear the procedural hurdle. Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell held the vote open for an hour Thursday morning, as he waited for Republican Senator Johnny Isakson, flying in Thursday from his home state of Georgia, to land and rush over from the airport. Recovering from two back surgeries, the most recent performed on March 15, Isakson had gotten clearance from his doctor to return to Washington Thursday 鈥渇or one day only,鈥 said a spokeswoman. He used a walker to navigate the Senate floor. Elsewhere, he was seen being pushed in a wheelchair by an aide. (McGrane, 3/30)
Republicans argue rescinding the rule doesn鈥檛 decrease funding for women鈥檚 health and that community health centers that don鈥檛 provide abortions can be an alternative if Planned Parenthood loses funds. Stripping Planned Parenthood of federal funds has long been a prime goal of social conservatives, though federal law prohibits the use of taxpayer dollars to pay for abortions, except in cases of rape, incest, or grave risk to the health of the mother. (Andrews, 3/30)
The legislation, which already cleared the Republican-controlled House on a largely party-line vote, is part of a series of bills being passed by Congress under the so-called Congressional Review Act, which allows federal regulations put in place during the final days of the previous administration to be undone by simple majority passage. (Mascaro, 3/30)
Senate Republicans 鈥渄idn鈥檛 listen to women across the country who made it clear that restricting women鈥檚 access to the full range of reproductive care is unacceptable,鈥 said Washington Democrat Patty Murray. Republicans 鈥渁re already gearing up to attach riders to budget bills in order to cut off critical services at Planned Parenthood to millions of patients,鈥 she said on the Senate floor. (Rowley, 3/30)
The Obama administration's rule was finalized in December in response to 13 states that denied Planned Parenthood federal funding for family planning and maternal health, which is provided under Title X of the 1944 Public Health Service Act. The program has provided about $286 million annually in recent years to certain health providers and Planned Parenthood receives about $25 million of that money. (Siddons, 3/30)