Morning Briefing
Summaries of health policy coverage from major news organizations
Viewpoints: Parents Of Autistic Children Counter Kennedy's Claims; NIH's New Diet Trials Doomed To Fail
Maverick is magic. At four years old, he gently pets flowers and belly laughs when a strong wind blows. He loves to hug his big brother. Maverick is also severely autistic, and according to our new U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., he鈥檚 part of a group of children who 鈥渨ill never pay taxes, they鈥檒l never hold a job, they鈥檒l never play baseball, they鈥檒l never write a poem, they鈥檒l never go out on a date,鈥 as Kennedy said on Wednesday. (Linda Blackford, 4/22)
Imagine a clinical trial with sedentary, overweight adults. One group is assigned to remain sedentary, the other to undergo intensive physical training with daily runs, calisthenics, and sports. After a week or two, the training group would probably feel sore and tired, and their endurance might be reduced. But we wouldn鈥檛 conclude that physical activity is bad for health. Clearly, we鈥檇 need a better, longer study to see the benefits. (David S. Ludwig and Mary E. Putt, 4/22)
On Tuesday, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Kennedy v. Braidwood Management, a case in which an employer is arguing that the formation of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) violates the Constitution鈥檚 appointments clause. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) regulations require that employer-sponsored health plans cover USPSTF-approved preventive care without cost sharing. The Supreme Court鈥檚 eventual decision could leave employers with important decisions about coverage for preventive care. (Jeff Levin-Scherz, 4/22)
I know all too well the fear and isolation many young people with cancer experience. Cancer is always a lonely proposition, but it鈥檚 especially so for young adults. The loneliness I experienced was pervasive. Older people, mostly my parents鈥 friends, didn鈥檛 understand, and my contemporaries often struggled because I had the dubious distinction to be their first friend facing a life-threatening illness. One grad school colleague told me years later, 鈥淚 just didn鈥檛 know how to be your friend once you were diagnosed.鈥 (Steven Petrow, 4/21)
Dr. Van Scoy sees acceding to requests for unproven medicines as a 鈥渟lippery slope.鈥 When doctors prescribe medications that they don鈥檛 believe in, even ones that pose little risk to the patient, it can cost them the trust of their colleagues. Families might question why their doctors give in to some requests and not others. She believes that what patients and their families really need is honest and open communication surrounding doctors鈥 decisions and the time to build confidence in their providers. (Daniela J. Lamas, 4/20)